Most frequently asked question: So, what do you think about Spider-man One More Day, Part 2

This is part 2 of a 3-part post. Part 1.

Before we go any further, I want to make a brief stop so I can look for something in my long boxes in the other room. Ah, here it is. Indulge me for just a moment.

Amazing Spider-man #274

Amazing #274 Amazing Spider-man #274, set during the height of Secret Wars II when the omnipotent Beyonder was being a major threat to reality/general nuisance. Someone had said the wrong thing to the Beyonder and he was close to erasing all of existence as though it had never been. Not even Mephisto was safe and he knew it. So when the gulliable but wildly dangerous Beyonder came at him, Mephisto bought himself time to prepare treachery by offering up a wager. The wager would be each would chose Mephisto would chose a virtuous hero to represent the value of existance and the Beyonder would select a terrible threat to put them into a situation where they would have to go against a belief they held dear. The Beyonder allowed Mephisto no choice at all and gave him Spider-man as his champion, the Beyonder chose for himself Mephisto's prisoner, the vengeance demon Zarathos himself. That's right the same unforgiving, unrelenting, Zarathos who was once bonded to Johnny Blaze as Ghost Rider. The wager was afoot, but would only buy reality twenty-four more hours instead of the millenia Mephisto was hoping for.

While going about his usual duties of not having any money or time to spend with Aunt May and Mary Jane, Spider-man stumbled unto a plot to assassinate Wilson Fisk, the Kingpin of Crime. The hit was to go down in a very short time at the Kingpin's favorite restaurant, and now the game would begin for Mephisto and the Beyonder. As Spider-man contemplated on exactly how he would prevent the assassination despite Fisk's nature, Zarathos appeared to him and barked that the Kingpin clearly deserved to die and he should do exactly nothing. The monster, who Spider-man had no knowledge of in his true form, cast realistic illusions of Spider-man's greatest regrets and failures upon him. The then late Norman Osborn battling Spider-man as the Green Goblin, asking why Spider-man had not found a way to save him. Visions of Peter Parker's disappointed parents. The cruel Zarathos even plagued our hero with honest-to-goodness boils before appearing as a miffed Captain Stacy and pretending to give Spider-man another chance to save Gwen Stacy who is of course still dead. The Beyonder was soaking up the drama although it was getting to be a little much even for him, Mephisto grew more and more twitchy at the prospect of losing his own wager.

The moment of truth was finally at hand after all the torture and visions, Zarathos appeared before the beseiged Spider-man in a masked physical form. The Kingpin left for his dinner reservation, the assassin already in place. Spider-man was little match for Zarathos, but upon appearing to gain the upper hand, Spider-man unmasked his assailant, to reveal Zarathos' final attack. Under the mask is, of course, dear Uncle Ben who reminds Peter Parker how he disappoints everyone, is locked in a pattern of trying to help people who will just ask more and more of him, and a prisoner of his own responsibility. All Spider-man has to do to get this emotional agony to stop is just forget everyone else, live for himself, enjoy life. That's all he has to do.

The hour tolls as time is up for the Kingpin and it appears that the Beyonder has won although he isn't terribly excited about it. But somehow, some way, Spider-man rises to his feet amid the demon's mystic assault. Spider-man tell Zarathos that everything the visions have said are pretty much true and that he should probably stay down, but he has someplace to be. He can't knowingly let a man die, not even the Kingpin. There is no reason why Spider-man carries such an overwhelming sense of responsibility on his shoulders, but "that's the way I was brought up..that's the person I've always been." He then delivers a left hook to Zarathos that send him straight back to Mephisto's prison, and then takes out the sniper that was set to finish the Kingpin, who will never know that he owes his life to Spider-man. Mephisto has bought reality another twenty-four hours and the Beyonder perhaps has learned something about the strength and potential within a brief mortal life. Great issue, huh?

The point of this long and drawn out synopsis of a random issue from 1985? Firstly, this is the only time Spider-man has interacted with Mephisto. Mephisto had, of course, heard of Spider-man and was not thrilled at the prospect of him being his champion with all of existance, himself included, hanging in the balance. Spider-man would never know why he came under such attack that day or what was at stake. But most importantly, Spider-man did not take the deal offered to him. Spider-man did not relent to stop the pain, even though it was such a simple thing to do. Why? The reason why is the reason Spider-man is the character he is, the reason why he got his own series after Amazing Fantasy #15. He is the hero and his strength comes from the ideals that he was raised with ie: he does not take the deal that the bad guy offers. He does not accept the villain's terms which are guaranteed to have side effects. He does not negotiate with terrorists. Not without a plan for what happens next, anyways.

Spider-man: One More Day Part 4

One More Day 4 This is it. The last part. Our hero and his wife ponder the offer presented to them by the evil Mephisto. He can make it so Aunt May lives, but it will cost the couple their marriage. If they take the deal, May will live, but they will never have been married. They won't remember that any such bargain took place or that they were ever married. But they will each have some faint clue in the back of their heads that something had been lost. With time running out, Mary Jane wonders if it is perhaps May's time. If it were natural causes then Peter could accept that, but it was his unmasking that led to her being at death's door so he has to try and change this. Mephisto arrives for their answer, but is met with more questions which he does answer. The specific detail of their marriage will be removed from the past. Spider-man's identity reveal will be erased so the same thing doesn't happen to May or MJ again. They're down to seconds left for May and MJ accepts the deal, but with some sort of stipulation that she whispers to the demon. But it does not work unless they both take it. Frustrated and out of options, Peter Parker accepts Mephisto's offer. Spider-man makes a deal with the devil. At this time Mephisto reveals that the charming little red-headed girl from before was the the daughter that the Parkers were destined to have. Gone now because of the deal they just made to disolve their marriage from history in exchange for Aunt May's life. Things like that are exactly why you don't deal with Mephisto, a lesson Peter and MJ learned the hard way. Just a few seconds left and MJ assures Peter that they will find their way back again someday, not even this will keep them apart. Quesada provides a great double-page splash of their good times together, then its all over. Peter Parker wakes up in Aunt May's house, where he lives, grabs a wheat cake for the road and heads out to a special get-together. The gang is all there, Flash Thompson, even MJ though the two keep their distance for reasons to be revealed. The guest of honor arrives and it is Harry Osborn. Fresh out of rest and rehab in Europe. Somehow the deal that was struck with Mephisto resulted in Peter's friend and sometimes foe, Harry, living instead of dying. Here's to a brand new day.

So that's what happened. Spider-man made a deal with the devil. The more I type that the less right it sounds. In the store recently, recently overheard a customer explaining the story to a relative who did not read comics. He said to her that Aunt May had been shot by a gunman and in order to saver her life, Peter Parker had made a deal with he devil. Ghost Rider making a deal with the devil, sure I can take that without blinking. Because there it precident for it. But for Spider-man to do that, well it doesn't sound right. There's no way to make it sound right. Impossible. The reason I dug Amazing #274 out of my boxes to re-read is because not only is it the only interaction between Spider-man and Mephisto that I've read until now, it is a prime example of how Spider-man never takes the deal. Until now. And an institution that has been in place since I was buying new issue of Spider-man off the shelf is expunged. Peter Parker is not only not married to Mary Jane, he never was.

...continued in part 3.